3 piece crank v 1 piece

[Mr Nice]

whats best and why?

[CD17]

For riding or show 

I think 3pc are best for both, look loads better & are stronger 

[meticulous]

depends what for, i think 3 piece look better and may be slightly stronger, and are much more expensive, but its for show bike then a one piece can be just as effective if done correctly...

[Mr Nice]

For riding or show 

I think 3pc are best for both, look loads better & are stronger 

For racing

[meticulous]

then a good 3 piece will be slightly better,but stay away from the surgino o/s cranks, i used to bend the bottom brackets spindle for fun, and always reverted back to a 1 piece...

[TwoBobRob]

What he said   

[jT Racing]

then a good 3 piece will be slightly better,but stay away from the surgino o/s cranks, i used to bend the bottom brackets spindle for fun, and always reverted back to a 1 piece...

 
what are you? 30 stone.
never ever had a problem with a sugino crank. maxy cross was pretty strong. I'd like to see one of these bent spindles.

[harris]

if you mash a part or bend a piece its easier to change on a 3 piece
with a 1 you got to rip the lot out.

[Voodoocars]

I run Primo hollowbites now but bitd my mate had those diamondback cranks that are like macneils twin tube things now and he cracked those. I had a sugino alloy 3pc that was just rubbish and wouldnt stay tight on the spindle.So I tried different 1 pc cranks that bent and in the end put a 1 pc off a burner- dont know what model- and had no trouble at all apart from having to tighten the bearings all the time.Heavy tho'.Although weight wasnt an issue all those years ago...  Depends what you want the bike for and how much you want to spend I guess.

[meticulous]

then a good 3 piece will be slightly better,but stay away from the surgino o/s cranks, i used to bend the bottom brackets spindle for fun, and always reverted back to a 1 piece...

 
what are you? 30 stone.
never ever had a problem with a sugino crank. maxy cross was pretty strong. I'd like to see one of these bent spindles.

i tried 3 piece in 1982/83, partly cos' they looked much better, and bent 2 spindles in a month, so went back to one piece (as i couldnt afford flites), maybe had a bad batch, dont know, but i was alright with a one piece



of course 3 piece cranks like this are much stronger and have no flex at all, but he didnt say what he is doing with his bike at first...

i will be sellin these soon anyhow, if anyones interested...

[pickle]

I run Primo hollowbites now but bitd my mate had those diamondback cranks that are like macneils twin tube things now and he cracked those. I had a sugino alloy 3pc that was just rubbish and wouldnt stay tight on the spindle.So I tried different 1 pc cranks that bent and in the end put a 1 pc off a burner- dont know what model- and had no trouble at all apart from having to tighten the bearings all the time.Heavy tho'.Although weight wasnt an issue all those years ago...  Depends what you want the bike for and how much you want to spend I guess.

i maybe wrong but all Burner 1 piece cranks were Sugino...i can remember mine like it was yesterday as i had to regreese the bearings every bloomin week! 

personally though i prefer the look and feel of 3 piece